Hereās a shocking truth: while Australiaās housing market has been on a rollercoaster since the COVID-19 lockdowns began in March 2020, the story isnāt as straightforward as you might think. Itās not just interest rates driving the show. In fact, the gap between house price growth in cities like Brisbane, Perth, and Adelaide versus Sydney and Melbourne has been nothing short of dramatic. But hereās where it gets controversial: if interest rates were the main culprit, wouldnāt all markets move in lockstep? They havenāt. And this is the part most people miss: local factorsāpopulation, jobs, wages, supply, and demographicsāare the real game-changers.
Take a closer look at the data from PropTrack: while home values in Brisbane, Perth, and Adelaide have nearly doubled, Sydney and Melbourne have lagged far behind. Cotalityās daily dwelling values index reinforces this trend, showing that growth in the smaller capitals continues to outpace the big two. So, whatās really going on?
Michael Matusik, in a thought-provoking article (https://substack.com/@matusikmissive), argues that interest rates are more of a sideshow than the main event. They tweak behavior at the edges but donāt dictate prices. Instead, he identifies seven key drivers of housing growth, and theyāre all hyper-local:
- Population growthānot just any growth, but a meaningful surge above long-term trends.
- Employment growthāthink stable, high-quality jobs, not short-term gigs.
- Real wagesāinflation-adjusted incomes that keep pace with rising costs.
- Tight supplyālow resale stock, scarce rentals, and limited new builds.
- Undervalued housingālocals buying, renovating, and investing as early signs of value.
- Demographic mixāyoung buyers and upgraders, not just downsizers.
- Educationāstrong school catchments creating high-demand micro-markets.
Now, letās talk numbers. Alex Joiner, chief economist at IFM Investors, shared eye-opening charts (https://x.com/IFM_Economist/status/1955864975253365085) that highlight the divergence in working-age population growth across states. By July 2025, Queensland, Western Australia, and South Australia were significantly ahead of pre-pandemic trends, while Victoria lagged and New South Wales stayed on track. This mismatch in population growth mirrors the housing price disparitiesāno coincidence there.
But wait, thereās more. The supply side of the equation canāt be ignored. Brisbane and Perth are grappling with a shortage of homes for sale, while Sydney and Melbourne are relatively well-supplied. This imbalance further fuels the price gap. Is it fair to blame interest rates when local dynamics are so clearly in the driverās seat?
Hereās a bold question for you: If interest rates arenāt the primary driver, should policymakers focus more on addressing local issues like population growth, job creation, and housing supply? Or is there another factor weāre all overlooking? Letās debate this in the commentsāIām eager to hear your take.